FaultScore

1996 Subaru Outback engine problems

11 of the 57 complaints about the 1996 Subaru Outback are about the engine — 19% of everything reported for this model year. Half of the failures with a mileage on record happened before 115,000 miles.

B

11

Complaints

0

Crashes

0

Fires

0

Injuries

Exactly what failed

Engine 6 54.5%
Engine AND Engine Cooling 3 27.3%
Exhaust System 2 18.2%

Engine & Cooling across every Subaru Outback year

1996 11 1.1%
1997 29 2.9%
1998 46 4.6%
1999 28 2.8%
2000 41 4.1%
2001 26 2.6%
2002 22 2.2%
2003 19 1.9%
2004 16 1.6%
2005 27 2.7%
2006 50 5.0%
2007 18 1.8%
2008 20 2.0%
2009 18 1.8%
2010 67 6.6%
2011 93 9.2%
2012 52 5.2%
2013 68 6.7%
2014 36 3.6%
2015 50 5.0%
2016 56 5.6%
2017 43 4.3%
2018 36 3.6%
2019 40 4.0%
2020 52 5.2%
2021 23 2.3%
2022 22 2.2%

What owners said

Filed with NHTSA, in their own words.

at 100,000 miles Mystic, CT

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING

WHILE DRIVING VERY BUSY HIGHWAY, THE TEMPERATURE GAUGE WENT ALL THE WAY TO "H". I PULLED OVER AND NOTICED SOME STEAM UNDER HOOD. ADDED SOME WATER. A LITTLE LATER, STILL ON "H". MECHANIC WHO HAS SERVICED MY 1996 SUBARU OUTBACK SINCE I GOT IT IN 1998 SAID IT HAD A BLOWN HEAD GASKET, COMMON WITH SUBARUS. IN 2009 I HAD THE 90K MILE MAINTENANCE DONE, VERY EXPENSIVE. ALSO HAD ALL NEW BRAKES, VERY EXPENSIVE. ALSO FOUR NEW TIRES AND LAST MONTH, A NEW BATTERY. ALSO, LAST MONTH, HAD OIL CHANGE. I HAVE NEVER RECEIVED EVEN ONE RECALL NOTICE FROM SUBARU, EVEN THOUGH THEY KNEW ALL ALONG THAT THEIR HEAD GASKETS ARE FAILING IN THEIR CARS. I WANTED MY OUTBACK TO LAST MANY MORE YEARS BUT NOW MUST JUNK IT BECAUSE OF A FAULTY HEAD GASKET. MECHANIC SAID IT'S USELESS TO FIX HEAD GASKET OR REPLACE IT, AND TOLD ME TO GET A NEW CAR, WHICH I CANNOT AFFORD. MECHANIC PUT CHEMICAL IN LINE WHICH IS SUPPOSED TO SEAL ANY LEAKS (NO GUARANTEES). I OFTEN VISIT MY DAUGHTER, WHO IS RECUPERATING FROM BREAST CANCER, IN THE NORTHEAST PART OF CT, IN A VERY SECLUDED AREA OF FEW HOMES, NO BUSINESSES. TO HAVE CAR FAILURE IN THE WOODS WOULD PROBABLY GIVE THIS 70 YEAR OLD A HEART ATTACK.

NHTSA complaint #10299746 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

at 166,000 miles West Milton, OH

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING:ENGINE

CAR OVERHEATED WITHOUT WARNING. SUSPECT HEADGASKET FAILURE ALLOWING COOLANT TO ESCAPE AND ENGINE TO OVERHEAT . (POTENTIAL FOR CAR TO UNEXPECTEDLY STALL ON INTERSTATE) UPON INTERNET SEARCH FOUND THAT HUNDREDS OF THE SUBARU 2.5L ENGINES SUFFER FROM SAME CONDITION (1995-1999). HTTP://HOME.COMCAST.NET/~SKIPNOSPAM/.

NHTSA complaint #10289921 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

at 161,423 miles OAK Grove, MN

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING:ENGINE

1. JUST BOUGHT FROM DEALER. GOING TO GET GAS. 2. OVERHEATING. AUTO MECHANIC SAID OIL IN THE ANTIFREEZE. HEAD GASKET. 3. REPAIRED HEAD GASKET ETC.

NHTSA complaint #10225852 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

at 185,000 miles Wasilla, AK

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING

CAR SEEMED TO BE RUNNING FINE BUT RADIATOR TEMP WAS HIGH. TOOK CAR INTO REPAIR SHOP, CRACKED HEAD GASKET. CALLED SUBARU, THEY OFFERED NO HELP OR ADVICE. COST TO REPAIR IS AT A TOTAL LOSS TO ME, A COLLEGE STUDENT. SUBARU DEALER SAID CRACKED HEAD GASKET IS A PROBLEM IN SUBARUS. I WOULD HAVE NOT BOUGHT THIS CAR IF I KNEW IT WOULD HAVE THESE KIND OF PROBLEMS. PART TO BE REPLACED IS HEAD GASKET.

NHTSA complaint #10145111 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

at 97,600 miles Utica, NY

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING:ENGINE

CAR STARTED AND RAN NORMALLY FOR 5 TO 10 MINUTES ALONG A COUNTRY ROAD AT ABOUT 45 MPH, VEHICLE SUDDENLY ACCELERATED TO FULL THROTTLE. POKED ACCELERATOR PEDAL A FEW TIMES WITH NO RESULT, AND PEDAL DID NOT APPEAR TO BE STUCK DOWN. HELD SPEED OF VEHICLE DOWN WITH BOTH FEET HARD ON BRAKE PEDAL. VEHICLE RETURNED TO NEAR NORMAL OPERATING CONDITION ON ITS OWN AFTER ABOUT 30 SEC TO 1 MIN, ALTHOUGH VEHICLE COULD MAINTAIN 30-40 MPH WHEN NOT TOUCHING EITHER ACCELERATOR OR BRAKE. RETURNED TO FULLY NORMAL OPERATING CONDITION AFTER A FEW MINUTES. THIS WAS THE SECOND OCCURRENCE IN LESS THAN TWO WEEKS. IN THE FIRST OCCURRENCE, VEHICLE WAS HARD TO START FOR SEVERAL SECONDS, THEN WHEN DID START RACED TO EXTREMELY HIGH IDLE FOR SEVERAL MINUTES. POKING ACCELERATOR PEDAL HAD NO EFFECT. VEHICLE RETURNED TO NORMAL OPERATING CONDITION AFTER BEING TURNED OFF AND RE-STARTED. VEHICLE WAS BROUGHT TO DEALER, BUT TECHNICIANS COULD NOT DUPLICATE PROBLEM, AND ALL DIAGNOSTIC CHECKS WERE NEGATIVE. PROBLEM IS STILL UNRESOLVED.

NHTSA complaint #10102225 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

at 115,000 miles Eagle Mountain, UT

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING:EXHAUST SYSTEM

BLEW A HEAD GASKET WHICH LEAKED ANTIFREEZE THROUGHOUT THE ENGINE CAUSING MANY OTHER PARTS FAILURES. FOR EXAMPLE, O2 SENSORS. TOTAL COST OF REPAIRING VEHICLE - $4,800

NHTSA complaint #10069547 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

at 115,000 miles Eagle Mountain, UT

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING

BLEW A HEAD GASKET WHICH LEAKED ANTIFREEZE THROUGHOUT THE ENGINE CAUSING MANY OTHER PARTS FAILURES. FOR EXAMPLE, O2 SENSORS. TOTAL COST OF REPAIRING VEHICLE - $4,800

NHTSA complaint #10069547 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

at 115,000 miles Eagle Mountain, UT

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING:ENGINE

BLEW A HEAD GASKET WHILE TRAVELING WITH TWO CHILDREN. BROKE DOWN AND HAD TO WAIT ON SIDE OF BUSY ROAD WITH ONE YEAR OLD AND TWO YEAR OLD. THE CAR,A 1996 OUTBACK ONLY HAD 115,000 MILES ON IT. REAL LOW FOR THIS TYPE OF INCIDENT. *NLM

NHTSA complaint #10016569 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

Maspeth, NY

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING:ENGINE

THE REAR OIL PAN GASKET WAS REPLACED DUE TO LEAK.

NHTSA complaint #548376 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

Redlands, CA

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING:ENGINE

OIL PLUG BROKE RESULTING IN FAILURE.

NHTSA complaint #604988 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

Maspeth, NY

ENGINE AND ENGINE COOLING:EXHAUST SYSTEM

CONSUMER HAS NOTICED EXHAUST FUMES INSIDE THE VEHICLE WHILE DRIVING WITH THE WINDOWS UP.

NHTSA complaint #809454 — an unverified report by a vehicle owner.

← Full 1996 Subaru Outback report